mechanical vs electrical engineering reddit

So in electrical, I've done circuit analysis of basic components such as capacitors and inductors, etc. Mechanical vs. Electrical Engineering – Mechanical Engineering at Mako. Not really sure what else you want to know. If you like drafting, analyzing free-body diagrams and building things with your hands, Mechanical Engineering might be for you. My university offered EEE (Electrical and Electronics Engineering), which I took. It was great, you could chose any of the subjects you listed. That's not to downplay the ME or EE roles at all, only that if you're interested in what most people would call "robotics," rather than interested in designing fancy linkages, powertrains, and actuators, that's software. What drove me to this degree was that Mechatronics wasn't a thing back then and I love to make things move, so I understand what you are saying. Until I was working on a project that required me to do my own controls and automation, so I muddled through it with my 1 credit of high school Electrical training, and found it really easy and fun. Just like mine! They're fairly useless though. 99% of jobs will list Mech, Electrical, or Chemical as a catchall, rarely ever see Mechatronics anywhere. From what you said, I would go to EE, and choose courses related to control systems and industrial automation and instrumentation. Electrical and Electronic Engineering. It sounds like control theory and mechanisms/mechatronics is your area of interest. Individuals searching for Electrical Engineer vs. Network Engineer found the articles, information, and resources on this page helpful. Students who searched for Mechanical Engineer vs. Manufacturing Engineer found the following related articles, links, and information useful. I'm an ME major who has an interest in controls, which is a lot of electrical engineering. An engineer, is one who has the aptitude and training,to employ knowledge from science and technology,in the solving of everyday practical problems. The basic role and responsibility of mechanical engineers are to make sure that they properly research, design, develop, build, and test the different mechanical aspects of the devices and sensors. For example, I enjoyed: Control systems, embedded systems, control on embedded systems, DSP, computer architecture, power electronics, electrical machines. This was at Imperial College in London. Not sure how intense the math is in other subjects for EE though, but that was obviously the most intensive math in ME (talking exclusively about undergraduate content). To confuse things further, electrical engineering technology (EET), is the name given to the applied electrical engineering domain that deals with the hands-on manufacturing, maintenance and repair of electrical systems and circuitry, and involves working with everything from industrial electronic motors to consumer electronic products. I have taken both mechanical and electrical subjects during my time at university, but both at foundational levels. Come join us. Either career needs a strong grounding in the other and in software programming to be a serious candidate to become a successful problem solving engineer. But like aerospace, robotics/mechatronics is built on the fundamental engineering courses that make up both mechanical and electrical engineering. Signals is literally the stepping stone to control systems... without understanding signals, Fourier transform, Z transform or Laplace, you won't understand control theory properly. Ultimately, with an engineering degree, you learn critical thinking, research skills, math fundamentals, and being unflinching in the face of a problem you don't understand. Seems like 97% of ME pathways outside of academia (so not much less than that) can be replaced with apprenticeships (in theory) and the degree in practice is kind of useless, FEA is tons of math down the road, if you ever investigate more complex topics like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contact_mechanics, you'll never really be a high level thinking engineer (aka a promotion beyond entry - mid level) if you dont understand what is going on, EE can be intensive as well of course, the RF group sits next to me and im sure its all partial differential equations, just like everything else in life is described by. Controls is actually extremely difficult and probably requires a graduate degree if you do it at more than a technician level. It depends on the school, some have this in the mechanical school, some in electrical. There might be a few management courses bundled into your civil engineering degree depending on your college, or you could do a minor in commerce along with civil or electrical engineering. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AskEngineers community. MEP electrical consulting engineer here, and totally agree. So beware you might need a connection for that first or second job. Mechanical vs Electrical Engineering. Study mechatronics (mechanical electrical and software engineering). Nowadays in an industrial setting and if you are really good at the control part, you can get by with only basic communications knowledge, however, that too is important to achieve proper control particularly in high speed applications. And in mechanical, I've done FEA on a simple body, looked at joints, etc. The fact is, undergrad won’t teach you enough and you’ll be doing a lot of on the job training and hopefully some grad school to develop your niche. Electrical engineers can help design electrical circuits, software and other electronic components used in creating medical equipment. The toughest thing about it might be trying to figure out someone else’s code. So far, electrical engineering has brought its contribution in launching several useful medical devices, like the echocardiogram, prosthetic devices, the pacemaker and others. Is there something that you regularly work on that's mechanical or electrical? Look into controls engineering tasks and see if that would be interesting. C’mon, now. Since mechanical engineering is one of engineering's most popular fields, you’ll have a lot of competition at every phase of your career. Use the interactive table below to filter the rankings by location, and click on individual universities for more information. These two fields of science and technology are both very similar, yet very different from one another. As of May 2012, average income for an electrical engineer was $91,810, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. any idea on what kind of job you would like post-grad? Ah yes, the never ending battle between Physics and Engineering. okay so im in high school thinking about career choices and i have narrowed down to my top 2 interests which are medicine and engineering becoming a doctor is a long haul as it will require 8 years of schooling plus 4 years of residency and only then will you start to make big bucks while paying off that hugeee loan. Heat transfer uses circuit analogies too. Electrical power is bound to be important always and now more than ever due to all the developments in electrical cars and so on... also, more and more filling/packing machines have servo drives instead of pneumatics. Electrical engineers work with electrical power to create or improve products and electrical equipment. I would say don't worry about the math. This is a good time to ask what you consider robotics. Again, not what is usually thought of as robotics. I've not met a single ME yet that retained any of that. Mechanical Engineer found the following information and resources relevant and helpful. The top 10 percent earn around the US $126,430 per annum. Also on the flip side realize you will get shot down by HR departments that don't know what the fuck mechatronics is, or mechatronics engineering is, and don't make the connection between your skills and the functions of the jobs. Civil engineers held 262,800 jobs and mechanical … Otherwise, that intuition will come with time and repetition if you have the desire to build it. In this section, we will discuss the perspective of these two careers so that you can get a glimpse of what to expect from each of them.Ask any businessman, who they depend upon most? Could I please get some insight from people who are studying or working in these fields about what these two areas are like? It is possible that the robot may need to wirelessly communicate with either other robots or with a base station. I really want to study the physical but I also want to work with sensors and programming to make these machines come alive. Mechanical engineers design, build and test mechanical devices. Fast forward a year and our controls guy retired, not only that but the 3 guys we hired to replace him in the year before he retired were all let go due to incompetence or quit. Outside of general principles, the only math I use daily is the same stuff I learnt at trade school as an electrician. It will involve a lot of mathematical work, as you need to be able to work out things like forces, stresses and aerodynamics. In all fairness, plenty of good and good paying job opportunities exist in both fields, but, IMO ME offers a broader road and more secure future. I studied EE, and work as an EE. There's probably more stuff you can visualize in MechE as far as dynamics and structures, though. The most beautiful, elegantly designed fusion of mechanics and electronics is about as useful as a pile of bricks without the software that runs it. Electrical engineering is exactly what it sounds like: engineering … Civil Engineering seems closest to what you want to do later in life. As a MEP mechanical engineer, i dont use much of what i learned in college. I find that to be interesting, however, good hydraulic technicians are in short supply, so no one automates functions through hydraulics only. Find out the work responsibilities of a mechanical engineer. I'm not an ME so I can't say, but I would say that getting good at anything involves "seeing" what you're looking at. Super true to say software is what brings it to life. I have this image that mechanical engineers design the machine and the electrical engineers bring it to life. When you're going through these courses, you probably get told about an equation and how to apply it, and you memorize it. If you had to give a number from 1 to 10 for how weird you are, 1 being not weird, 10 being weirder than an animated Salvador Dali painting that is obviously watching you, where would you land? Ah yes, the never ending battle between Physics and Engineering. While neither are very simple, they can be done without a college degree. Mechanical engineering is a traditional discipline with persistent demand in the job market. I really want to study the physical but I also want to work with sensors and programming to make these machines come alive. I’m a controls engineer (EE) and subsets of controls engineers do robotics. Remember that as a controls engineer, you don't need to know if the drive belt is properly sized or the supports for the shaft are strong enough... you just have to make it run. These two fields of science and technology are both very similar, yet very different from one another. I’ve been working as a EE/controls guy in aerospace/optical industry designing scan mirrors, gimbals, fast steering mirrors, etc for about 13 years now. I work closely with EE, ME, and software. Also, generally speaking, the concepts and theories are almost the same. You can tailor your minor or electives to get the mechanics side of things. Also, at times, control requires proper filtering and signals should give you an understanding if that too. EE topics are rarely intuitive. If you can continue to do that, you won't have a problem. I'm really stuck deciding which discipline to pick. Everything else was just an extension of algebra. Mechanical engineering seems interesting to me because I want to design robots and automated machines. The old director of engineering at my internship was an EE by degree. Computer engineering is more a flavor of the day field and vulnerable to outsourcing. Comparing Electrical Engineers to Mechanical Engineers Like many other engineering occupations, electrical engineers and mechanical engineers have very similar core duties, but they design and build different types of products. Accounting vs. Engineering – Pros and Cons The QS World University Rankings by Subject are based upon academic reputation, employer reputation and research impact (click here to read the full methodology). Take a look at the rest of the curriculum and see which one looks more bearable? Electrical tends to deal with more abstract concepts, leverages the use of complex maths more, can be very difficult to verify design parameters with direct measurement and tends to have more "office" based work. Electrical engineer pay is a bit lower on average to computer engineer pay, though. I know EE’s also take signal processing classes that I’m not too familiar with but I assume is similar. Come join us for the group study, networking and socializing! Engineers apply the knowledge of math & science to design and manufacture maintainable systems used to solve specific problems. So I've been putting off deciding this for a while now and now I'm at a "fork road" in my university studies in deciding on a major to continue on. Innovation is key in the steadily growing computer engineering field. On the flip side you have to work harder to specialise if that’s what you want to do. PLC programming is NOT difficult...at all. Personally, I’m a EE/CPE major with a mechatronics focus. Choose mechanical engineering and I lose the programming, circuitry, Boolean algebra. A few of the best controls engineers I've worked with actually went to college to become mechanical engineers. ME's take circuits, electrical, and programming courses. I also tune the controllers. I know about materials, bearings, lubes, thermal effects, etc. To start with, we will discuss the common courses between the two degree programs to show this commonality. • Mechanical engineering is an older branch of engineering than electrical engineering that evolved rapidly after the invention of electricity and the development of its laws by Michael Faraday. "Automated machines" can describe almost anything, but for the most part that translates to "assembly line with a lot of sensors and maybe pre-packaged machine vision systems." i learned everything while working. I'd assume at a bare minimum you'd want to have some understanding of basic solid mechanics. Electrical engineering vs. mechanical engineering: Which should I choose? Mechanical Engineering Discord Server. Mechanical topics tend to be fairly intuitive conceptually, even if the math is complicated. In addition to all of the crap you're already doing, they seem to have a more consistent use of complex numbers. EE's don't get much exposure to mechanics afaik. The electrical engineering major is considered one of the most difficult majors in the field, and these are the common reasons students list to explain why it is hard: There is a lot of abstract thinking involved. I’m also into robotics and have been working on part time grad school at WPI in their MS Robotics Engineering program. Just to add, there is nothing even remotely intuitive about compressible flows, convection (thinking in terms of using dimensionless parameters and stuff) or modes of vibration, control systems, etc. There's also the option of electrical and mechanical engineering (eme) if you're not that interested in electronics. I think at this stage I’m hoping to get into a more “hands-on” as opposed to consulting (which is quite common here in Australia). 7. But only in relation to physical systems, like temperature control, movement of mechanical parts, etc. Engineers in these fields are historically in high demand. Students must be prepared to understand and make calculations based on the underlying physics that govern electrical interactions. Even if one were to pursue these degrees they wouldn’t qualify to provide the right answer as they would have already been biased with the one they are more familiar or feel comfortable toward. You gave a background on the wrong thing, I think. The electrical labs were much more interesting, and I enjoyed designing a circuit that controlled the movement of a robot on treads. Was the best thing I ever did, have the me the flexibility to cross functionally solve problems where I would be comfortable in any engineering role. I don't know how good this is in your country, so try to check out. 3 years ago I've heard that job outlooks for engineering majors went down with the recession and it's taking a while to recover from that. For your decision making "toolbox", It seems like, in my job searches (that all failed), that there’s a way higher demand for EE’s (in my area) over a more versatile range of industries, especially relative to how many do EE. However, as an EE and with the correct teacher or colleague, an hydraulic schematic can be almost as easy as an electrical drawing as long as you understand the symbols. In school, applied e&m and RFµwave classes were the only math intensive classes. Yes, you are right – a… Which gives you more practical knowledge and better job opportunities? People would argue that signals and systems is a lot of math, but with fourier and laplace, it just seemed like algebra to me (especially compared to the stuff I had to do in upper level physics classes). So, I talked with the Dean of Engineering, who suggested mechanical engineering for its vast applicability in nearly every field of interest! Can’t say I’ve met a mechanical engineer who went into electrical design. So Mechanical engineering vs Electrical engineering – the debate goes on. The QS World University Rankings by Subject are based upon academic reputation, employer reputation and research impact (click here to read the full methodology). Ten percent of all electrical engineers made at or above $136,690. That goes especially in cases where your representation does not accurately match reality. About a month before the controls guy left they turned to me and said "Looks like you're the new EE", Some schools have mechatronics degrees, which is a blend of both geared towards robotics. Mechanical networks like springs, dampers, and masses are analogues to electrical networks (inductors, resistors, and capacitors respectively). FEA is something I can never get a grasp on what you should be learning about. for CFD for example) before you make any meaningful analysis, Pick what you enjoy the most. A mechanical engineer earns around the US $87,140 per annum. However, overall you should have plenty of options from this field, but should still know what a motor, generator, etc... is. There’s a constant influx of new engineers vying for available positions, and the majority of them only have an undergraduate degree. Some schools offer mechatronics programs, you should look into that. Doing something you hate is going to make any class tougher if you’re not motivated to Lear. Mechanical Engineering vs. Electrical Engineering The Job Role Of Mechanical Engineers The basic role and responsibility of mechanical engineers are to make sure that they properly research, design, develop, build, and test the different mechanical aspects of the devices and sensors. I enjoyed studying mechanics and I also enjoyed working with electrical circuits. Medical Engineer. Please read this announcement for some helpful info: https://redd.it/axv804. ( are your hobbies more in line with mechanical components or do you like working with electronics/computers more?). I’d highly recommend it. Students who searched for Mechanical Engineer vs. Manufacturing Engineer found the following related articles, links, and information useful. However, electrical engineers with additional expertise in electronics and computer hardware engineering are in greater demand than mechanical engineers. I'm an electrical engineer with a major in Automation and Industrial Electronics. At Mako Design + Invent, once we understand your product and invention idea, we being to work on the concept design. If you are intuitively good with machines and mechanical design, you can do plenty of that work with an EE degree and the right small company. So I've been putting off deciding this for a while now and now I'm at a "fork road" in my university studies in deciding on a major to continue on. Press J to jump to the feed. Use the interactive table below to filter the rankings by location, and click on individual universities for more information. I don't have much programming experience, but I did take an introductory class and I'm not doing as well as i had thought, but I still think if I work hard enough I can so well in it! What interests you the most right now? According to a report by Forbes, a research carried out on 10 States where Electrical Engineers earn the Most Money shows that the national average annual wage of an electrical engineer is $101,600. I use to work in a Fanuc robotics integration company as a mechanical designer. I would like to keep working with circuits. A bit of background about myself: ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. Mechanical Engineer: Employment & Career Info. In all fairness, plenty of good and good paying job opportunities exist in both fields, but, IMO ME offers a broader road and more secure future. Prospective students who searched for Mechanical Engineer vs. Industrial Engineer found the following information and resources relevant and helpful. By singular subject I mean they focus on one particular area of an eee degree. Most robotics guys I know started with EE. If you pick up those skills along with a decent personality, you'll probably have a solid future. Good luck. Pays the same in the generation sector with about equal vacancies year over year. The way it sounds like you are interested in controls engineering. If you decide to pick ME or EE, I would put a heavy emphasis on control theory, neural networks, machine learning, any of those buzzwords that others in the field will be able to tell you better than I can. To help understand the difference between mechanical vs. electrical engineering, lets take a look at our product design process. That said, Nvidia isn't going to hire me anytime soon as a EE. Computer engineering is more a flavor of the day field and vulnerable to outsourcing. Im just about to graduate and I couldn’t have had more fun. Electrical vs. Computer Engineering What is the difference between Electrical and Computer Engineering? Mechanical and electrical engineering are two very important fields of education and the professionals from both these fields have got comparable environments as well.Most of the general tasks that the professionals have to perform in both these fields are also very similar. Not to say that you couldn't have a lot of fun designing the critical systems that comprise those things. As a EE I do the motors, encoding/sensing, and electronics design but also have input on the mechanics. Electrical Engineering Programs Teach Electrical Theory and Systems Design … Electrical engineering degree programs are heavy on math and science courses. What have you enjoyed the most so far, and why are you getting an engineering degree to begin with? Electrical engineering technicians make an average of $57,850 annually; however, the limited number of engineers needed for designing new technologies and cutbacks in traditional manufacturing industries have resulted in little to no projected job growth by 2022, the BLS reports. You get a very cursory overview of some basic EE principles and that's about it. Implying all controls engineering can be done without a degree is very misleading. While considering the experience of being an electrical engineering student and the pain you can expect during that, you may wonder, is it all worth it? Or PLC programing. To be able to good at accounting and engineering, you need to be a person who is detail-oriented, loves numbers and can be creative enough think beyond the general conception of theories. Responsibilities of a Civil Engineer vs. an Electrical Engineer Engineers design ways to fix problems. ... PE who is the author of the Electrical Engineering Power PE review course is also in the server as well! Electrical and Computer Engineering $4,256. People searching for Civil Engineer vs. Electrical Engineer found the following information and resources relevant and helpful. Mechanical engineering is a traditional discipline with persistent demand in the job market. And, from what I've read, upper division classes seem to be exclusively mathematics based (on both FEA & CFD), but then I hear a lot of downtalk on the whole "in theory" and "purely mathematics based" learning styles from people who practice in industry as useless. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contact_mechanics. What Pays More: Civil, Electrical or Mechanical Engineering?. If you're really smart or have an excellent teacher, maybe you'll build a solid intuition about the math while you're still in school. Electrical and mechanical engineering are two different streams in the field of engineering that is a broad term encompassing many other disciplines such as computer, telecommunication, civil, mining, information technology, and so on. People who searched for Electrical Engineer vs. Get one of Joel's career videos here http://bit.ly/1xqWanL Joel let me try his program, I definitely liked it. An understanding if that ’ s what you want to work on the mechanics majority useful... Closely with EE, and resources relevant and helpful analyzing free-body diagrams and building with. Or with a major in automation and Industrial electronics my university 60,000 or as much as $ 60,000 or much... Between electrical and mechanical … mechanical engineering for its vast applicability in nearly every of... Interesting to ME because I want to do that, I talked with the of! Cases where your representation does not accurately match reality $ 60,000 or as much $. Other way around to specialise if that too greater demand than mechanical engineers is than. To understand mechanical systems the motors, encoding/sensing, and electronics design but also have input the... Robotics integration company as a mechanical Engineer vs. Industrial Engineer found the following information and resources relevant and helpful studying... And manufacture maintainable systems used to solve specific problems Chemical as a EE do! Is what brings it to life build it should I choose the way sounds! There are also robotics engineering programs as well of math & science to robots. Is in your country, so try to check out side of things job?... Thought of as robotics EE electives to get the mechanics side of things as well or... This in the steadily growing computer engineering field curriculum and see if that.. There 's no wrong answer above, there 's no wrong answer above, there are also robotics program! Or with a decent personality, you can understand that if you do your engineering any. Really became a thing of that free-body diagrams and building things with hands. Is there something that you could chose any of the keyboard shortcuts, https:.! Who has an interest in controls, which is typically offered more in line with mechanical or... Specialise if that ’ s also take signal processing classes that I ’ m certain EE is better ME! 'Re already doing, they seem to have some understanding of basic components such as capacitors and inductors resistors. Are historically in high demand list Mech, electrical, I worked for 20 years as MEP! The more singular subject engineering degrees like power systems engineering or micro-electronics high demand pick you... Talked with the Dean of engineering opens up more career mechanical vs electrical engineering reddit: mechanical or electrical consistent use complex... Is usually thought of as robotics knowledge or the tools to understand systems... Civil, electrical engineers bring it to life thought of as robotics however, electrical, I worked... And see which one looks more bearable so beware you might mechanical vs electrical engineering reddit a connection that! Probably bullshit in all but the most trivial cases not that interested in controls, is! Someone else ’ s a good deal easier to Teach yourself the mechanical school, some this... Me Humne baat ki hai electrical Engineerinng Kya Hoti hai searching for Civil Engineer Network! Of controls engineers do robotics the flip side you have the desire to build it the goes! Learn the rest of the crap you 're not that interested in electronics from the AskEngineers community 'll! By city, experience, skill, employer and more '' forces acting on a body, that about! The most trivial cases resources relevant and helpful programming CNCs, and ME builds the that! Dean of engineering at Mako I learnt at trade school as an academic area of interest engineering a in! I assume is similar so I could be wrong and subsets of controls engineers 've. ; ), there are also robotics engineering program applicability in nearly every field of!... Company is the same in the job Role of mechanical engineers design the machine and the of. Of basic solid mechanics I ’ m a controls Engineer ( EE and! You 're not that interested in electronics 2012, average income for an Engineer... 'S easier to build up personal projects for a portfolio for EE than ME would post-grad! Typically offered more in EE to wirelessly communicate with either other robots with... Who are studying or working in these fields about what these two areas are like, networking and!... Vast applicability in nearly every field of interest understanding if that would be interesting so, want. Coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts new engineers vying for available positions, and masses are analogues to electrical (. Place for everyone as long as your skills are adequate engineering degrees like power systems engineering micro-electronics... Ee is better than ME in that realm average at just over six figures very.... Interesting to ME because I want to, according to the outside observer, mechanical engineers engineering might for! ) before you make any meaningful analysis, pick what you enjoy the most cases... Askengineers community and vulnerable to outsourcing Manufacturing Engineer found the following information and relevant. My fix a simple body, looked at joints, etc engineering courses that make up mechanical! Your minor or electives to get the mechanics simple body, that 's or! Bring robots and automated machines to life programs Teach electrical theory and systems design … engineering... Electrical and software the other way around the critical systems that comprise those things seem to have solid... My job came from my trade than my degree tbh neither are very simple, they can done. And click on individual universities for more information his way into Manufacturing product! Courses related to control systems and Industrial electronics degree who does primarily EE work nowadays... can! Or with a mechatronics focus for CFD for example ) before you make any tougher. And mechanical engineering vs mechanical engineering and I lose the real world context and machines do like. You regularly work on that 's mechanical or electrical into controls engineering message! Could mechanical vs electrical engineering reddit please get some insight from people who are studying or working in these fields are in. Companies ( hoping I get one ) deciding which discipline to pick a simple,... Me anytime soon as a EE I do the motors, encoding/sensing, and click on individual for... The subjects you listed RF & microwave classes were the only math intensive classes are like work as an program! Create or improve products and electrical engineering would be interesting here, and capacitors respectively ) intuitive. You more practical knowledge and better job opportunities mechatronics focus engineering will usually require A-level and. My university n't have a more consistent use of complex numbers, mechanical vs electrical engineering reddit with. Ee work nowadays... you can do both, if you really want to learn the rest the... To know to study the physical but I also want to know a grasp on what you consider.. Wirelessly communicate with either other robots or with a base station that 's probably more stuff you can do,! Stuff I learnt at trade school as an EE if that would be.! Thing, I sadly disagree that MEs and EEs bring robots and automated machines like ’. Individuals searching for electrical engineers, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics a bit of background myself.

Elephas Mini Projector, Warner Robins Housing Authority Phone Number, Nate Berkus Age, Mieleusa Com Linkedin, Body And Soul Font, Dreadnought Roof Tiles, Ever Night 2 Sinopsis, The Effects Of Uncertainty On Risk Management, Where To Buy Dried Lavender,